Why Won't My Dog Come Back When Called? The Real Reason

You have called the dog's name four times. It has looked at you once, weighed you against the spaniel on the other side of the field, and chosen the spaniel. Everyone in the park has heard you. If this is familiar, the problem is not that your dog is stubborn, deaf or "a bit of a character". The problem is what your dog has learned about you, and the good news is that it can be unlearned.

The Honest Answer: Coming Back Is Optional, and Your Dog Knows It

A dog that will not come back when called has learned, through hundreds of small repetitions, that returning to you is a choice it gets to make. Most of the time it chooses the more interesting option, because you are competing against squirrels, scents, other dogs and the sheer joy of running, and on a normal day in a Yorkshire park you will lose that contest.

That is not a recall problem. It is a relationship problem that shows up as a recall problem. The dog does not see you as the person who decides where it goes, so when you ask it to come, you are making a request rather than giving a direction, and the dog treats it as one.

How Your Dog Learned That You Are Optional

Nobody sets out to teach a dog to ignore them. It happens through ordinary habits that feel harmless at the time.

• The word was used too early. You said "come" to a twelve week old puppy that had no idea what it meant, it did not come, and from then on the word meant "a noise the human makes while I carry on". Once a word has been ignored a few hundred times, it is worn out. Saying it louder does not sharpen it.
• Recall was only ever practised at home. Your dog comes beautifully in the kitchen, because the kitchen has nothing in it. The field has everything in it. A dog that has only ever been asked to come back when there was nothing better on offer has never actually been tested.
• Coming back meant the fun ended. The dog came, the lead went on, and you went home. Do that a dozen times and a clever dog works out that the way to stay in the park is to stay out of reach.
• You called it for things it hates. Bath, nails, the car to the vet. The word that should mean "good things happen near my owner" became a warning.
• The dog leads everywhere else too. It pulls on the lead, rushes through doors, decides when it gets attention and climbs on the sofa when it likes. A dog that makes every other decision in its life will not suddenly hand that decision over in the one situation where it has the most freedom. If this sounds like your dog, our post on why dogs pull on the lead explains the same root cause from a different angle.

Why the Quick Fixes Do Not Work

Treats

The most common advice online is to make yourself "more rewarding" with high value food. Chicken, cheese, hot dog. For some dogs this works right up until the moment it matters, which is exactly the moment the dog is more interested in the deer than the cheese. You have taught the dog to run a calculation, food versus the thing it wants, and in the real world the thing it wants will sometimes win. A dog that comes back for food is responding to its stomach, not to you. We do not use food in training for precisely this reason.

Whistles and gadgets

A whistle is just a word that is easier to hear. If the dog does not want to come to the word, it does not want to come to the whistle either. The same goes for vibrating collars and apps. The equipment is not the problem and it is not the fix.

Shouting, chasing and the angry voice

Chasing a dog teaches it a brilliant game. Shouting teaches it that coming back leads to a telling off, so it will arrive slower and stop further away, or not arrive at all. Telling the dog off when it finally does come back is the single fastest way to destroy whatever recall you had left.

Just keeping it on the lead for ever

Plenty of owners give up and keep the dog on a lead or long line permanently. That is safer than a dog running loose with no recall, and we would rather you did that than risk the dog, but it is management, not training. The dog still does not look to you. It is just attached to you.

What Actually Changes a Dog's Recall

Everything that works starts a long way from the field. It starts at home, with the dog learning that you decide direction, that your attention is worth having, and that following you is the most natural thing in its day. A dog that follows you around the garden without being asked, that checks where you are before it does anything else, has done most of the work of recall before a single word has been taught.

Once that relationship exists, recall becomes something you build on top of it, step by step, in places that get gradually harder, without ever asking the dog to do something it is not yet ready to do. The word is added late and protected carefully, so it only ever means one thing. Off lead freedom is earned once the dog has shown you, in ways you can actually see, that it will stay close and stop when told. Give a dog that freedom too early and you are back to square one.

How long that takes depends on the dog and on you. A young dog with no history of ignoring its owner can get there surprisingly quickly. A four year old that has spent three years deciding when it comes home will take longer, because there is unlearning to do first. Either way, it is weeks and months of consistent work, not a one hour class and a bag of treats. We have written about realistic timescales in How Long Does Dog Training Actually Take?

What Recall Looks Like When It Is Right

You say the word once, in a normal voice. The dog turns away from whatever it was doing, including another dog, and comes straight to you, all the way, without a detour. It does not need to see your hand go to your pocket. It does not slow down ten metres out to check whether the lead is coming. It comes because, in its world, you are the safe place and the place where the good things are, and it trusts that whatever happens next will be fine.

That dog can go on the moors, the beach and the canal towpath. It can be off the lead in a busy park in Leeds or Sheffield without you holding your breath. That is the freedom most owners want when they get a dog, and it is available to almost any dog, but it has to be built in the right order.

Where to Start

If you have been battling recall for months, the most useful thing you can do is stop practising failure. Every time the dog ignores you in the park, the problem gets a little more set. Put the dog on a lead or long line, keep it safe, and get the relationship looked at properly.

Every dog that trains with us starts with an in person assessment at our Leeds/Wakefield or Sheffield centre: up to an hour with an accredited trainer, watching how your dog moves with you, where its attention goes and what it believes about who makes the decisions. From there we build a plan for your dog, not a generic one. Over 7,000 dogs have been through that door, and almost half of their owners had tried other training first. Recall that failed elsewhere is one of the most common reasons they come to us.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Dog Training Company · Leeds · Wakefield · Sheffield