Which Puppy Should You Pick From a Litter? | The Dog Training Company
Getting a Dog
The breeder you buy from is one of the most important decisions you'll make as a dog owner — and one of the most overlooked. Most people spend more time researching a new appliance than they do vetting the person who raised their dog for the first eight weeks of their life. Those eight weeks shape everything that follows.
A good breeder isn't just someone who produces healthy puppies. They're someone who understands the breed, raises puppies responsibly, and cares enough about each dog's future to ask hard questions of the people buying them. Here's what to look for.
Deep Breed Knowledge
A breeder who has chosen to produce puppies should be one of the most knowledgeable people you'll ever speak to about that breed. They should be able to tell you about the breed's temperament, exercise requirements, health tendencies, training challenges, and how they typically develop from puppy to adult.
If you're looking at a crossbreed, they should be equally knowledgeable about both parent breeds — including how the combination tends to affect temperament, coat, size, and health. Vague answers about breed characteristics are a warning sign.
Health testing is non-negotiable. Every breed has specific health conditions that responsible breeders test for. Hip scoring, eye tests, DNA tests for breed-specific conditions — what's required varies by breed, but a good breeder knows exactly what applies to theirs and can show you the results. If they can't, walk away.
A Proper Rearing Environment
How puppies are raised in their first eight weeks has a lasting impact on their temperament, confidence, and adaptability. Puppies raised in clean, stimulating environments — exposed to household sounds, different surfaces, gentle handling, and human interaction — develop into significantly more stable adult dogs than puppies raised in kennels, sheds, or isolated conditions.
Ask to see where the puppies actually live — not just where they're presented to you.
Be cautious of breeders with multiple litters from different breeds running simultaneously. A breeder who genuinely cares about the socialisation and development of each litter cannot do that properly at scale. Volume breeding is a warning sign regardless of how professional the operation looks.
They Ask You Questions
The most reliable indicator of a good breeder is that they interrogate you as much as you interrogate them. A responsible breeder cares deeply about where their puppies end up — and they won't place a puppy with anyone without understanding the home it's going to.
Questions a good breeder should ask you
- What is your home environment — house, flat, garden, children, other pets?
- What are your working hours and who will be with the puppy during the day?
- Do you have previous experience with dogs or this specific breed?
- What is your plan for training and socialisation?
- Have you researched the breed's exercise and mental stimulation requirements?
A breeder who lets you pick a puppy without asking anything about you is not a breeder who's thought carefully about where that puppy is going. That should concern you.
Red Flags to Walk Away From
Warning signs in a breeder
- Puppies available immediately with no waiting list
- Multiple breeds or multiple litters available at the same time
- Unable or unwilling to show health test results
- Won't let you see where the puppies are raised
- Offers to meet you in a car park or neutral location
- No interest in your home, lifestyle, or experience
- Pressure to decide quickly or pay a deposit immediately
The puppy farming industry has become increasingly sophisticated at presenting a professional front. A clean website and professional photos are not evidence of a responsible breeder. The questions they ask you — and the environment they show you — are.
A Good Breeder Is a Long-Term Resource
The relationship with a good breeder doesn't end when you take the puppy home. A responsible breeder will want to know how the puppy is getting on, will answer questions throughout the dog's life, and will take the dog back if your circumstances change rather than letting it go to an unknown home. That commitment tells you everything about how seriously they take what they do.
Not sure which breed is right for you?
Use Our Breed Finder
Before you find a breeder, make sure you've found the right breed. Our quiz helps you identify the dog that suits your lifestyle.
Find Your Breed →